Nature and Nurture Resolved-Juniper Publishers

 JUNIPER PUBLISHERS-OPEN ACCESS JOURNAL OF INTELLECTUAL & DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES


 

Opinion

The ageless faux controversy of nature v. nurture continues to haunt the otherwise scientific literature of behavioral biology. One classic example-the evolutionary value of the opposable thumb-encapsulates the essence of unnecessarily conflicting attitudes in this useless confrontation.

The standard saw offered by anatomists is that the pseudo-opposable thumb of New World anthropoids (e.g., Cebus) monkeys is mechanically limited to movements in one dimension-left and right-and thus limits the behavioral range of monkeys condemned to secondary evolutionary status by this structural inhibition. By way on contrast, Old World anthropoids were blessed with opposable thumbs which permitted swivelling action which in turn opened the way for humans to develop tool use as the pathway to biological predominance. Unfortunately, this is not true.

A concerted study of manual prehension in anthropoids-a battery of tests examining eight different aspects of grasping- proved that while humans (Homo), with opposable thumbs, are superior to all other species in grasping objects, the second best genus was Cebus, with their supposedly limiting pseudo- opposable joint. Next in efficiency were opposable thumbed Pan (chimps) and some Old World monkeys (Rhesus and Patas) and then some pseudo-opposed species Saimiri (squirrel monkeys) and Callimicos. Skipping the fact that perhaps humans were superior because a human created the tests, Cebus monkeys were the curve-busters. But for them, the anatomists would have been correct; the opposable thumb is an enabler, and pseudo- opposable thumbs a limitation. However, the fact remains, the Cebus monkeys (think organ-grinder partners) out performed all non-human genera tested.

How can this be? The answer is in the life style of Cebus. In their natural habitat, they are actively engaged in interacting with their environment. One example should suffice to make the point. When discovering a stump invested with edible termites, a Cebus monkey will tear apart the decaying wood to convert the insects into food. When placed in a cage which is held shut by a chain tightly tied by a handler but within reach of the imprisioned animal, it deftly unties the chain and escapes. These are the monkeys trained to assist quadriplegics: upon verbal request/ command, they will open a refrigerator door, take out a bottle of sodda pop, open it, put a straw in it and place so the patient can sip it. They are as intelligent as they are deft in using their hands.

So, among anthropoids, nurture (life experience) trumps nature (genetics). If we place an-thropoids at one end of a continuum-say in the left side, all other forms of animal life can be strung along to the opposite end where on finds instinct driven insect and arachnids. Anthropoids, and other mammalian genera, produce few offspring per generation, and those few develop slowly and learn to interact with their environments. At the other extreme, insects, other invertebrates and perhaps even some fishes, produce prodigious numbers of offspring per generation, but their behavioral repertoires are extremely limited. The young develop rather quickly, with essentially no learning along the way. Survival is usually assured by the vast numbers of siblings, only two of which need to survive to reproduce and continue the genetic line.

Thus, nurture (learning) reigns among anthropoids and nature (genetics) at the other extreme where simple instinctive patterns of behavior suffice for survival of the species.

For more Open Access Journals in Juniper Publishers please click on: https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/juniper-publishers

For more articles in Open Access Global Journal of Intellectual & Developmental Disabilities please click on: https://juniperpublishers.com/gjidd/index.php

For more Open Access Journals please click on: https://juniperpublishers.com

To know more about Juniper Publishers please click on: https://juniperpublishers.business.site/

 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Report of a Clinical Case in Agoraphobia: The Challenge to Fly-Juniper Publishers

Image
  JUNIPER PUBLISHERS - OPEN ACCESS JOURNAL OF INTELLECTUAL & DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES Abstract This is a report of a clinical case in which the patient wishes to modify dysfunctional avoidance behavior, in order to be able to confront his fears of elevators, high places and planes. The presence of activator tasks between sessions as motivation for the final objective was of significant importance. Cognitive behavior therapy was used as base methodology. It was concluded that it is an effective and tangible treatment for the agoraphobic, providing assistance and bringing success and applicability in this case [ 1 ]. Keywords: Agoraphobia; Systematic desensitization; Cognitive behavior therapy Introduction This study has the objective of reporting a clinical case of cognitive behavior therapy, which is short term structured therapy, focused on the resolution of problems. Acc...
Read more

Effect of Embedded Sensory Stimulation in the Design of Learning Framework for Increasing Attention Span of Children with Autism-Juniper Publishers

Image
  JUNIPER PUBLISHERS - OPEN ACCESS JOURNAL OF INTELLECTUAL & DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES Abstract The inattention deficit in children with autism has made teaching a challenge for teachers, parents and caregivers. This inattention also affects the triad of impairment: social, communication and pattern of behavior associated with them. Education has been identified as a relative cure for their impairments and use of technology as a medium for learning has been said by different studies as an effective way of teaching children with autism. Hence, some studies have come up with learning frameworks for developing educative software applications which focus on gaining the attention of the children with a learning disability such as autism during learning. Thus, this review presents existing learning frameworks in developing effective software learning system for children with autism. Keywords: Autism; Learning framework; Sensory stimulations ...
Read more

Cannabinoids in Autism and Fragile X Syndrome: Value-Based Treatment Revolution Ahead? -Juniper Publishers

Image
  JUNIPER PUBLISHERS - OPEN ACCESS JOURNAL OF INTELLECTUAL & DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES Introduction Cannabis has a long history in Central and South Asia, as it was used to produce hemp fibre for rope, clothing and paper, but was also consumed both for recreational and medicinal purposes. The two major neuro active components in cannabis are the psychoactive A9-tetrahydro-cannabinol (A9-THC) and the non-psychoactive cannabidiol (CBD). Recent years have seen a resurgence in interest in the therapeutic potential of compounds derived from cannabis, due to significant advances in our understanding of cannabis ingredients and endogenous brain cannabinoid (ECB) system, which consists of G-protein- coupled cannabinoid (CB) receptors, endocannabinoids such as N-Arachidonoylethanolamide (Anandamide) and 2-Arachidonoylglycerol (2-AG), synthetic and degradative enzymes, and transporters. Common medical conditions for which marijuana is allowed in the US (i.e., t...
Read more